St. Louis · Midtown · Barbecue
Pappy's takes no reservations at all: its own site says it operates first come, first served, and serves each day only until it sells out — it advises calling ahead later in the day for exactly that reason. It is closed Tuesdays.
Pappy's Smokehouse is hard to get into for the opposite reason most places on this list are: there is no book at all. Every seat is first come, first served, and the kitchen serves each day only until it sells out — so the competition isn't a booking window, it's the line at the door and the sellout clock behind it.
| Address | 3106 Olive St, St. Louis, MO 63103 |
|---|---|
| Neighborhood | Midtown |
| Cuisine | Barbecue Restaurant; American Restaurant; Restaurant |
| Price level | $$ |
| Rating | 4.8 from 1,358 reviews |
| Phone | +1 314-535-4340 |
| Official site | Pappy's Smokehouse |
There is no trick and no window to beat: Pappy's Smokehouse seats first come, first served and serves each day only until it sells out. The reliable move is to arrive before the rush, not during it. Coming later in the day? Call ahead (+1 314-535-4340) — the restaurant itself advises it, because on sellout days service simply ends early. And don't plan on a Tuesday: it is closed Tuesdays. No watch can scan a book that doesn't exist — what we can do is keep you first in line for the reservable St. Louis rooms we do track.
Page data refreshed 2026-11-02. Facts come from the public directory listing for Pappy's Smokehouse.
| The Best Steak House | Steakhouse |
|---|---|
| Eleven Eleven Mississippi | New American |
| Blood & Sand | New American |
| Carmine's Steak House | Steakhouse |
| Hamilton's Urban Steakhouse and Bourbon Bar | Steakhouse |
| Clark & Bourbon | Steakhouse |